Superior Chamber of CARF manifests itself on “split-without-split” operation
There is distortion of the rule provided for in art. 2249 of Law 9,249/95, when deliberately seeking artificial incidence through corporate operations aimed solely at evading capital gain, the “separate-without-separate” operation materializing, a new version of the old “house-separate” operation.
The asset subject to disposal of the legal entity is transferred to the withdrawing partner (ie, there is a separation between the asset and the legal entity), by means of an artificial capital return, without demonstrating the actual occurrence of loss situation. irreparable assets or excessive capital in relation to the objective of the company.
Precisely this asset that was the object of separation of the legal entity, in the return of capital, is sold to the acquirer by the withdrawing partner, who has a more favorable taxation than the legal entity previously holding the asset.
In reality, the asset never “separated” from the legal entity. It was artificially transferred so that it could be disposed of by a more taxable person.
It separated from the legal entity without actually separating because the transaction took place between the legal entity that originally owned the asset and the acquirer and not between the withdrawing partner and the acquirer.
Decision 9101-004.506
More information: reginaldo.santos@correiadasilva.com.br
About The Author
Partner
Advisory and Tax Litigation Nucleus
Category: CONSULTATIVE AND ECONOMIC LITIGATION, Reginaldo Angelo dos Santos, TAXATION
Tags: capitalgain, corporateincometax, correia dasilva advogados, CSLL, IRPJPosted in: 17/01/2020
See also
https://correiadasilva.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/citacao-via-whatsapp-1.jpg
667
1000
Correia da Silva
https://correiadasilva.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/Logo-csa.png
Correia da Silva2021-04-20 08:00:412021-04-20 06:44:00Quote Made by WhatsApp
https://correiadasilva.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2020/03/imagem-blog-3.jpg
187
295
Correia da Silva
https://correiadasilva.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/Logo-csa.png
Correia da Silva2020-03-04 14:52:112020-03-04 14:52:11Federal taxation on remittance abroad in the acquisition of a software license for commercialization or distribution
https://correiadasilva.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/imagem-blog-37.jpg
187
295
Correia da Silva
https://correiadasilva.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/Logo-csa.png
Correia da Silva2020-01-29 18:25:252020-01-29 18:25:25The Attorney General’s Office of the National Treasury – PGFN, regulates the disclosure of the list of debtors
https://correiadasilva.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2020/01/imagem-blog-36.jpg
187
295
Correia da Silva
https://correiadasilva.com.br/wp-content/uploads/2019/07/Logo-csa.png
Correia da Silva2020-01-28 15:24:382020-01-28 15:25:40Full payment of the tax debt extinguishes the punishment of the accused of tax evasion crimeSobre o autor
